Pine Island

About Pine Island

Pine Island is a compact neighborhood tucked off the main roads on the mainland side of New Smyrna Beach. Nearly every home sits on one loop street, Pine Shores Circle, and a few short side streets, and all of them went up within a few years of each other in the late 1980s, so the homes share a similar size and style.

Water runs through the middle of the community: many homes back up to a canal or a lake, which brings water views and a place to paddle a kayak. One homeowners association covers the whole community, and its fee is low and billed yearly.

Amenities and community

The community has its own pool and clubhouse, with a shuffleboard court next to them. The New Smyrna Beach Golf Club is close by, and Hidden Lakes Golf Club is a short drive away.

Location and getting around

Pine Island sits west of US-1, near Wayne Avenue and the city golf course, a few minutes from the Canal Street downtown. The beach and Flagler Avenue are about 10 to 15 minutes away over the North Causeway, and SR 44 and I-95 are a short drive for trips to Daytona Beach, Orlando and DeLand.

Homes in Pine Island

Homes are one-story, two- and three-bedroom houses built from 1987 to 1989, most with a garage. Sizes run from about 1,152 to 1,456 square feet. On canal and lake lots, check the shoreline and the flood zone on each listing. Right now 4 homes are for sale, asking from $334,000 to $394,000, with a median of $362,000.

Fees and rules

Every home belongs to the Pine Island Homeowners Association, which owns the pool, the clubhouse and the common areas. The fee is billed once a year and is low, about $380 to $400 a year in 2026. There's no CDD. Rental rules are set by the association, so ask for the current minimum lease before you buy. Fees change over time, so check the current amount on each listing.